The three candidates are the original one, the one that made it famous and today’s. Once again, we have entered an unwinnable, unprovable argument. Still, it’s fun to compare and even more fun to hear it debated - live - at your local pub.
The old-timers point out that team play was at its best back then. By “back then” we’re including the NBA all the way up to the 1969-70 Knicks and the 1971-72 Lakers. Proponents will claim that sound fundamentals were more prevalent (admittedly because the players didn’t possess the innate ability of today’s freakish athletes). Only the best played because there were only eight teams (1960, 14 in 1970), salaries were such that players had off-season jobs - and that didn’t include shooting commercials for endorsement deals - the men played for the true competitive aspect of the sport so winning was of paramount importance (playoff shares weren’t pocket change for the superstars, but coveted income) and guys had roommates on the road. The people claiming this era say over and over, the game was pure. Note: it is somewhat of a stretch including the ‘69-’70 Knicks and the ‘71-’72 Lakers in this group but the line had to be drawn somewhere - and it’s my blog.
What wouldn’t be a stretch is making the statement that the best and most dominant team of all-time was Red’s (and Russell’s) Celtics. A team composed of Cousy, the Jones boys (Sam and K.C.), Ramsey, Heinsohn, Luskie, Nellie (yeah, that Nellie), Satch, Hondo and, of course, the greatest winner ever, Big Russ himself. Before anyone says that era was simply the NBA’s version of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, consider the ‘69-70 Knicks of Clyde (talk about style & class), Monroe, Bradley, DeBusschere and the captain, Willis Reed and the ‘71-’72 Laker dream team of former great Bill Sharman, made up of the Logo, Elgin, Goodrich and the greatest athlete who ever lived, Wilt.
Chronologically, the next era was the one that introduced the world to the NBA. It was the time ruled by the “Showtime” Lakers, the Bad Boys of Motown (that’s Detroit, for those who just recently arrived in this country) and Michael & the Jordanaires. This is the one that gets my vote because of teamwork, superstars and entertainment value. It tops the three eras discussed in this blog. Remember, it’s my blog - feel free to post comments if you agree/disagree.
It was a time of salaries the common folk could understand, if not see in their own pay stub (I still recall the amazement over Magic’s 25-year, $25 million contract with Los Angeles), teams clinging to the idea that roommates helped players bond (which is especially true when those stories are told today), a league that expanded the number of teams but simultaneously expanded the pool of talent, with not only black players as the norm rather than the quota, but also foreign-born players (making it the real world-wide sport). Teamwork and sizzle could be found when watching the Lakers of Magic, Scott, Worthy, Perkins and Kareem. Teamwork and muscle were on display when the Pistons won back-to-back titles with cocky, but talent to match Isiah, classy 2 guard Joe Dumars, instant “O” off the bench with the microwave, Vinnie J, the enforcer, Rick Mahorn, the originator of the “pick-and-pop” center (as opposed to “roll”), Bill Laimbeer, and a tatoo-less, relatively normal (i.e. pre-Madonna), rebounding machine named Dennis Rodman. Putting together teamwork, flash and D - as well as six championships - the Chicago Bulls of Pippen, a less than normal, but still rebounding machine, Rodman, Horace Grant, Ron Harper, shooters Paxson & Kerr, center by committee and the best who ever played, MJ, showed the world how the game was meant to be played.
There was no dearth of confidence during this time, either, as a rookie point guard decided he’d play center when his mentor was injured (and Magic pulled it and the Finals’ MVP off), coupled with the famous (and identical) lines, first by Larry Bird (when, during a time out late in the game, head coach K.C. Jones was hesitant about which play to call), “KC, just give me the bleepin’ ball and everybody get the hell out of the way” to Doug Collins’ explanation in the post-game press conference of the play they called that won it: “We call it the ‘Give the bleepin’ ball to Michael and everybody get the hell out of his way’ play.” I’m not one who enjoys trash-talking, but at least, back then, you had to be great to do it, not after one shot block become a fool who will stare his opponent down, pound his chest and shout expletives, yet, as one current head coach mentioned recently to his team, be a guy “who hasn’t yet pissed a drop in this league.”
Magic showed us all how a 6′9″ guy could play the point, Bird how the “common man” type of superstar, someone who wasn’t particularly quick or could jump all that high, could steal an inbounds from a guy as talented and smart as Zeke, feed DJ and win an all but lost contest and MJ could go out night after night and get everyone to want to “Be Like Mike.”
Today’s game, with fewer fundamentals, but greater natural skill (Kobe, KG), with team play taking a back seat to physical, overpowering dominance (Shaq, Amare, Dwight Howard and, of course, LeBron - 275 pound LeBron), yet with a group of point guards from Jason Kidd and Steve Nash to Chris Paul and Derrick Rose as good as any who’ve ever put on a uni - from any era - is still an entertainment phenomena. To America -and the rest of the world’s - youth, it’s the only basketball they know and it’s more popular than ever. So how can someone knock the current style of ball - even if there is more jumping teams, complaining publicly about minutes, shots or strategy? Keep in mind if the internet had been around in earlier times, maybe the eras would be closer to the same in certain areas. There’s remarkable talent although it’s watered down due to expansion, e.g. Washington, Charlotte and Oklahoma City (is there really a team in Oklahoma City?) makes it possible for teams like the Celtics, Lakers and Cavs to acquire such glossy records. (Oh yeah, there used to be teams in Fort Wayne and Rochester, huh)?
This type of talk will surely raise blood pressure and bring out loyalties, with everyone having their favorites. Who knows who’s truly the best? The best line, by far, that I’ve heard when it came to comparing eras was the one the great Bill Russell said in response to a reporter’s question: “Bill, how do you think you’d compare against the centers of today?” Big Russ paused, looked at the scribe and calmly said:
“Young man, I think you have that question backward.”�