Fans Love Their (Winning) Coaches
Monday, November 26th, 2012Apologies for not alerting you I was going to be out of town. My wife and I went to see our younger son, Alex, play for Cal State Monterey Bay. He’s doing very well, especially for a freshman. Leads the team with a 17 points per game average. The team is 3-2 as it heads into conference play.
At my age (let’s call it retired), it’s easy to get caught up in reflecting. One thing I’ve found has never changed is the attitude fans have toward their coaches. Since most of my professional life was spent at the college level, my comments are slanted in that direction. What I discovered regarding the high school level was that the fans’ feelings for the coach had more to do with their kid’s playing time than anything else.
A few years after we moved to Fresno, the Bulldogs had a football coaching change to make when Jim Sweeney retired. The choice came down to Pat Hill (the eventual winner) and Brian Billick (a winner elsewhere). The pick was the right one. Billick won a Super Bowl. Hill gave Fresno State something much more precious: a pioneer of a program builder. As opposed to merely a program builder.
I worked at nine different colleges and can tell you early on that Pat Hill would do things not too many other college football coaches would have done. This blog’s not about all that but, suffice to say. I know of no other head D-I football coach who would run - and I mean, actually run - “car shows” in order to supplement his budget. Football coaches are known to simply demand what Hill worked for: a practice field, a strength and conditioning center, an academic center and other things that are necessary to win. He’d been an assistant here and bled for the school, thought it should be on a higher stage.
And he won. The community was gaga with Hill. His problem was his confidence (combined with a stubborn streak) - neither a strange trait for a football coach. He said the goal at Fresno State was not only to win the league championship but to play the big name teams and beat them so the Bulldogs would have a national reputation. At first, it was fun because they actually won some of those games, nearly every one of them as a visiting team. People in Fresno were proud to be Bulldogs, walked around with their chests out and heads high. They loved how he included everybody in the San Joaquin Valley by affixing a green V on the helmets (to this day, each of the FSU sports has a V somewhere on their uniform or equipment). They also loved his smash mouth style of football. Who doesn’t want to pound, and hang out with, the Big Boys? To anyone who understands big-time athletics, however, this philosophy was akin to Russian roulette. Fresno State began to do what was expected when smaller budget schools play the big cheese spenders (BCS). Making things worse, Fresno State never won their own little conference, the WAC.
Except once. The Bulldogs managed a three way tie for the championship. Fans were worried because there was talk others were interested in their favorite coach. When he interviewed with the Oakland Raiders, prayers could be heard throughout the Central Valley. Whew, he stayed. But then times (and budgets) got leaner. And, of all things, Boise State wound up doing what Pat told everybody could be done - without playing the big teams, just winning. But, also, never losing. So not only was it bad, but it became worse because one of their own conference teams actually did it - and Boisians chests were puffier and heads higher.
Believe it or not, the fans turned on Hill. Many said (and claimed they always felt that way, even when the Bulldogs would beat a BCS team) the Boise State theory was the way to go about it. “Just win your conference” (and every other game you play) “and you’ll crack the BCS.” New coach Tim DeRuyter came in and proved he was a good listener. Changed offensive and defensive philosophies immediately. He said the team’s goal was, first and foremost, to win the conference. “Yeah,” said the faithful (I always thought that was an interesting moniker, considering the definition), “that’s what we’ve been saying all along. Win the conference.”
In his very first year, the Bulldogs did exactly that. The offense was wide open which the fans adored (the fact they scored a lot more helped too) and the change from a 4-3 to a 3-4 defense delighted the fans - the majority of whom I doubt could diagram either, especially when they’d have to put the Xs in against Os and include all eleven players. Coincidentally, the championship was a three-way tie. They changed conferences (MWC), although the best teams in the new conference were, with the exception of San Diego State, the same as the best teams in the WAC - and, sadly as far as competition goes, the worst teams in the MWC being even worse than the worst in the WAC.
Tim DeRuyter’s name has made the rounds as a hot candidate (his name was mentioned, albeit among many others for the University of Tennessee job. The football team is preparing for its well-deserved bowl game. The community is once again praying their beloved coach stays home. For a while.
Lou Holtz’s famous line regarding fans and coaches:
“A perfect year for the fans is when the football team goes undefeated - and they fire the coach.”