Only the Participants Remember the “Almost” Upsets
Friday, March 20th, 2009When the Final Four comes around, everyone is busy talking about who will cut down the nets and rooting for their favorite squad - because they might be an alum, might know or live by an alum, professor, administrator, coach or, if they’re fortunate enough, a player. Or maybe they have a small (or not so small) wager or their bracket is still in the running for the top prize for their office pool.
However, during the first two rounds, while all of the above still applies, there’s another reason people get so geeked for the tournament: to see the major upset take place - and the bigger, the better. Since no #16 seed has ever knocked off a #1 (even though that is what the world, except for the #1 who eventually goes down, longs for), a #15 over a #2 will do nicely in satisfying the public’s desire for a David vs. Goliath story.
In history, there have been four such upsets, the first one pulled off by my friend and fellow New Jersey native, Dick Tarrant.  Dick coached one of my college buddies at Passaic HS (see my 9/13/08 blog entitled Why High School Coaches Do It for a little more about the impact high school coaches had on my three best buds in college and the coaches we tried to one-up each other about when we got to college).  As a matter of fact, my college classmate, Paul Dolinoy (see 1/28/09 blog), played with a guy named Lou Goetz, at Passaic on a Dick Tarrant-coached team.
Louie went on to be an assistant coach, his final stop at Duke, before accepting the University of Richmond job. When Lou was hired (and this says something to the character of both men), he felt he could use some veteran help on the bench, and turned to his old high schol coach, Dick Tarrant. It had to have been 30 or more years since Dick was an assistant and he had no desire to ever coach in college (he’d been offered a few smaller college head coaching jobs due to his overwhelming success on the prep level, which he turned down because he liked living where he was and saw no reason to leave).  For all the success Dick Tarrant’s had in coaching, you’d be hard pressed to find a guy who has his ego in check more than Dick.
To help his former prep school player, he accepted and the Tarrants relocated to Richmond, VA. Wouldn’t you know it, but after, I believe, just one year and a reasonable amount of success, considering what they inherited, Lou (possibly in a moment of “Is that all there is?), decided coaching wasn’t his real passion but he made the statement at such a time that the easiest route for Richmond athletics to take was to name Dick interim head coach.
All he did that year was lead the Spiders to the NIT. Interim tag removed, Dick coached 12 seasons in all - with success beyond belief considering the (lack of) emphasis and money Richmond spent on men’s basketball, but it was in his tenth year when he pulled the biggest miracle up to that time when his Spider team, which received a #15 seed, took on the powerful Big Orange of Syracuse - and beat them! It truly had “shocked the world” since it was a first and one that no one ever truly believed would happen. Â
In the years following, (’93, ‘97 and ‘01, Santa Clara beat Arizona, Coppin State beat South Carolina and Hampton beat Syracuse) there have been three more 2 vs. 15 upsets and yesterday, there was nearly another as Cal State-Northridge led for a good portion of the game and had #2 seeded Memphis on their heels. Finally, talent won out (and a little recuiting, giving the Tigers more depth than the Matadors) and Memphis advanced with an eleven point win.
Years from now, a much greater percentage of people will forget the outcome of this contest - because Northridge came up short. But you can bet it will still be vividly imprinted in the memory of those who made the trip, because as Michelangelo said:
“It’s better to try and do something great and fail, than to try to do nothing and succeed.” Â