While tradition is something to be proud of, it’s also something that often clouds reality. When Tubby Smith finally felt uncomfortable enough at the University of Kentucky - after averaging 27 wins a year and making the NCAA Tournament field every year he was head coach - he left for, of all places, that basketball hotbed, the University of Minnesota, meaning Tubby thought it would be more fun and rewarding (although not from a financial standpoint) coaching at a school, and in a community, known more for hockey and fishing than for hoops.
Kentucky, because they currently own the record for more college basketball wins than any other school in the country, thinks that fact means they’re #1! A great deal of those victories came a long, long time ago, when, even the most ardent supporter was probably being potty trained. Since the good ol’ days, hundreds of basketball programs in the country have been trying to match Kentucky’s prowess in the sport. Don’t look now, UK fans, but North Carolina is about to swoop in and overtake your beloved Wildcats. No one wants to be the coach at Kentucky when North Carolina passes them for most wins ever. Can anyone even fathom the amount of pressure on UK’s coach if UNC is one behind and both teams play on the same night?
A couple major factors in becoming a power are: 1) one player (of course, he must be the right one), can raise the level of play - and the win totals - all by himself and 2) it’s not a sport where there is a tremendous amount of money involved - in terms of facilities and equipment. So, since the Baron, Adolph Rupp, roamed the sidelines, many up and comers and even, some “Johnny-come-lately’s” are creating quite the stir. Subsequent to the “man in the brown suit” retiring from coaching, teams such as Gonzaga, UNLV and even UConn, have hit the national stage and become powerhouses, the latter two having won National Championships.
Yet, tradition is something we cling to, like the mini-basketball given to every male baby born in the Bluegrass State - a practice no longer legal (and if you don’t believe me, check out the 508 page NCAA manual Jim Calhoun referred to yesterday’s game). UK basketball got so good it had to move out of their campus facility Memorial Coliseum and that was so long ago that, the new home, cavernous Rupp Arena is now outdated.
So when it comes to coaching at a place like this, everything is bigger. Salaries, expectations, media scrutiny, fan involvement in the program (there are a few chapters in the 508 page NCAA Manual strictly devoted to fan invovlement). When a coach gets the Kentucky job, he’d better be incredibly ready to be overwhelmed with requests for everything and anything, all of which take up valuable time.
Each coach since Rupp - from Joe B. Hall on, seems to have had a presence, all of them incredibly confident and passionate. When I was an assistant at Tennessee from 1980-87, Joe B. was finishing his tenure as Lexington’s number one most admired/despised man (and some fans were members of both clubs). I don’t think Joe B. had thought about retiring as coach. It’s just that he wasn’t the old man, so any loss that wasn’t acceptable (which was every loss) was blamed on him.
At this time, Kentucky had done whatever was necessary to set themselves apart from the rest of the basketball world by constantly one up’ing their competition with ideas the rest of the nation didn’t think of, or do, or couldn’t afford, e.g. Wildcat Lodge (which the NCAA deemed was illegal and subsequently, cancelled all athletics dorms). Many in the coaching profession used to kid that Kentucky had the best team money could buy. There were so many stories, undoubtedly most are apocryphal, but even if 95% are fabrications or exaggerations, the other 5% put UK in another world.
I think Kentucky got the reputation that if there was a problem, the answer was throw money at it. This philosophy carried over to coaches too. If one wasn’t producing, get rid of him - independent of how much the school (or community members) had to come up with to relieve him of a job they deemed over his head.
Essentially, Joe B. Hall was forced out (even though he had won a National Championship) and, wouldn’t you know, the year it happened, the Final Four was in Lexington. Rumors were rampant as to who was coming in to replace Joe B. Since the annual Coaches’ Convention is held in conjunction with the Final Four, every coach in the country would be there. It seemed as though cameras were everywhere, especially in the lobby of the coaches’ hotel headquarters. Sportscasters were interviewing every coach who walked by. The late Abe Lemons, who coached at Oklahoma City, Texas and Pan American was the all-time funniest coach, as well as most irreverent, who ever prowled the sidelines. When a reporter asked Abe if he would be interested in the Kentucky job, Abe deadpanned, “Yeah, and they wouldn’t even have to pay me.” He paused for effect before saying, “All I want is the same deal Rick Robey got.” Robey was UK’s 6′10″ center and, naturally, paying a player would be the ultimate in breaking the NCAA rules.
The line got a great laugh - from everyone but the UK faithful. The man who eventually got the job was Arkansas coach Eddie Sutton, who, early in the process, made the statement, “I’d crawl from Fayetteville to Lexington for this job.” It turned out Sutton, a highly successful coach (one of a only six coaches to take four different college teams to the tourney), would wind up crawling, but it was out of Lexington, as he left in shame, under a cloud of an NCAA investigation.
At this time, long-time head coach C.M. Newton, a UK alum who’d played for Rupp, was UK’s director of athletics. He knew exactly which coach he wanted to hire. His choice was Rick Pitino, who had just finished a stint in the NBA, coaching the New York Knicks. He inherited a program on NCAA probation and immediately captured the hearts of Kentuckians by producing a winner - squeezing every drop of hustle and skill out of them. Eventually, another NCAA Championship banner would be hanged in the rafters.
After Pitino left to coach the Boston Celtics, Newton already had decided who the next coach would be and he felt the guy was a “can’t miss” coach. Once again, he proved to be a prophet when he selected Orlando “Tubby” Smith, who is responsible for the last NCAA Campionship banner, hanging in Memorial Gymnasium.
The stress and demands of the job, along with the criticism he started to receive, mainly because he hadn’t won another National Cahmpionship weren’t giving Tubby the ROI (return on investment) he deserved and he must have come to the conclusion it was time to leave.
No problem. UK had the perfect replacement in one of Pitino’s former Wildcat assistants, none other than back-to-back National Championship coach, Billy Donovan. Make that one problem. Donovan turned down his former employer.
Did panic set in? Or did the university just try to get a workaholic, a coach who was currently successful and someone with a deep passion for the game. Billy Gillespie turned around the program at UTEP and then left and had accomplished similar results at football-minded Texas A&M. A quick, whirlwind courtship and UK had their man.
Conflicts would break out due to basketball consuming Gillespie’s life and, suffice to say, the chemistry at UK just doesn’t wasn’t working. Toss in a trip to the NIT and a recipe for disaster was imminent. So Gillespie’s gone. Donovan has already come out with a statement, claiming he’s not interested and the list is Missouri’s Mike Anderson (who’s on a roll and, independent of what anybody says, Missouri has a better shot at getting to the Final Four than about 340 other D-I schools, including Kentucky), John Calipari, Jay Wright, Rick Barnes and Tom Izzo, each of whom are deified in the respective state they’re in and may keep the rumors floating around because of the economic situation in the country. After the way Tubby Smith left and now, the way Billy Gillespie’s dismissal is being handled, many coaches (particularly the ones who’ve been mentioned), may use the opportunity to interview as leverage. With all the success those guys have had, UK may or may not get any of the top notch coaches.
One they can have, and a coach with a good, albeit short, track record is UK alum Travis Ford, currently the coach at Oklahoma State. However, some may see Ford as a Matt Dougherty, an alum of UNC, but whose experience level was limited - and UK fans remember how that situation turned out at Carolina. Unfortunately, Kentucky doesn’t have a Roy Williams, an alum who had always said the best job in the country and most people in the know felt Roy would eventually wind up at UNC.
The job is not as attractive as it once was. Today’s kids aren’t as enthused about Kentucky as they were in my day,or even as they were, say, 20 years ago. The problem with Billy Gillespie was not his coaching and he’s a master recruitier so it looks like there’s not going to be a dearth of talent. Allegedly, Gillespie’s personality is what expedited his dismissal. He violated the second half of Jack Welch’s rule:
“If you’re good at what you do and get along with people, you’re 90% of the way there.”