College and Pro Ball Are Totally Different for Coaches
Friday, January 4th, 2013Yesterday’s blog talked about professional football coaches getting fired. Also about them getting hired. One thought on hiring is to bring in a (very) successful college head coach. There is a great debate about whether a college guy can make it in the professional ranks, that the pro game is so different than its college counterpart (and vice versa). History goes against the college guys. Fewer are successful when they make the jump than are career pro coaches.
One reason for the poor success rate is that, usually, the college coach who moves to the pros gets to take on a bad job. The good teams can’t afford to take a chance on a college guy because if he were to fail, heads would roll. A losing franchise can take a shot because, hey, nothing else has worked. Why not give a big college winner a shot? Mostly, though, losing franchises are losing - year after year - because of circumstances a mere coaching change won’t fix.
In the early ’80s Larry Shyatt, Scott Duncan (currently head and assistant coach, respectively, for the undefeated Wyoming Cowboys) and I started an annual self-improvement clinic for (basketball) assistants. Our original group was limited to about five or six of us. One of the coaches in our group was Jeff Van Gundy who, when he began attending the clinic, was as a graduate assistant for Rick Pitino at Providence. He was elevated to full-time status the following year (when Pitino left to coach the Knicks) and then moved to Rutgers (when the PC staff was let go after one year). After the Scarlet Knights gig, he became an assistant coach with the New York Knicks under Stu Jackson, a former Pitino assistant at Providence, who got the Knicks’ job when Rick left for Kentucky. Follow all that? Coaches always seem to be on the move, either to improve their position (usually through contacts), to stay just ahead of the posse, or because they got canned. Note: Stu Jackson is currently vice president of the NBA. A main part of his job is to levy fines. I wonder if he misses coaching?
The purpose for that diatribe was to let the reader know that Jeff Van Gundy does have college coaching experience. OK, back to the story. After years of these clinics, we would bring in other coaches to hear some fresh ideas. One year, Tom Crean came to share the philosophy and toughness drills of his program, Michigan State. A question was brought up about what they did following a home game. Tom explained how, once the post-game press conference ended, he would bring whatever recruits and parents had been at the game (mostly local recruits on unofficial visits) to the coaches’ office so they could visit with Tom Izzo.
Upon hearing this, Van Gundy, who by this time, was the head coach of the Knicks, leaned over to me and said, “Man, that’s why I could never go back to college. When the game’s over, I just want to get the hell out of there.” I said, as if he didn’t remember, that recruiting was all about relationships and stuff like that got everybody closer. Then I asked him something I could never understand about coaching in the pros. “How do you coach guys somebody else picked for you? I guess that’s why the guys with clout were taking the dual position of head coach/general manager. Everybody knows the better your players are in college, the better the team is.”
His response shocked me. “I would never want to be both coach and GM.” He went on. “I don’t have the time to check out all the guys who are going to be drafted. There are seniors, underclassmen and foreign guys. Plus, all those free agents. No, thank you. Coaching is so time consuming as it is. Now, it’s essential to have a great relationship with your front office, so they bring in players you can coach, your type of guys. Most of the guys who get fired in our business don’t lose their jobs because they weren’t good coaches.”
I consider myself to be a fairly wise person. After speaking with Jeff Van Gundy, I learned something I’d never realized prior. The college coaching profession and the professional version are almost completely different entities. And that goes football as well as basketball.
This quote by Chip Bell sums up that day for me:
“Effective questioning brings insight, which fuels curiosity, which cultivates wisdom.”