In the SEC Tournament finals, Mississippi State, at the beginning of the tourney considered by most on the outside looking in as far as NCAA Tournament selections went, played the #2 team in the nation, the University of Kentucky. The game plan was simple: win and no roomful of suits could exclude you from the Dance; lose and hope those same suits, most of whom undoubtedly had never stepped foot in Starkville, would be impressed with your showing. Option A was an infinitely better strategy than Option B - or any other letter, in any other alphabet.
For most of the 40 minute game, MSU did just that. They were beating UK and answered every Wildcat bucket. Late in the most important game of the Bulldogs’ season, they had managed a three point lead. UK brought the ball across midcourt and, with five seconds to go, their coach, Rick Stansbury, elected to play the odds. With Kentucky having at least three clutch shooters - John Wall, Eric Bledsoe and Patrick Patterson (not the three best three-point shooters in the nation, but when the chips were down - maybe because of the presence of Wildcat Nation, or maybe because of the pressure of it - these guys seemingly came through for their team), Stans had ordered a foul.
The “should you foul with a three point lead and under 10 seconds to go so they can’t tie it with a three or should you just play good, solid defense because crazy things can happen” philosophy was about to be put to the ultimate test - the finals of a conference tournament with an NCAA bid on the line. As a matter of full disclosure, I am, and always have been a proponent of fouling in this situation. Maybe it’s because I’m a math guy and think it’s a wise move from a percentage standpoint or maybe it’s because I’ve seen too many guys hit late game threes (see my blog from a couple days ago), but it just seems like the sensible move to make.
After the first free was made, everyone in the arena knew an intentional miss was coming. Now, let’s stop and think. If you are one of the MSU players lined up on the lane, whether on the inside position or in the third spot, you know that if you secure the rebound - and the way the rules are set up, it’s to your advantage, as you have both inside spots and four of the six on the lane - it’s virtually impossible for your team to lose. You’d be ahead by two and, at the very least, would be shooting two free throws with under five seconds to go - odds that are astronomically in your favor.
Add to that universal thought the extra bonus of being named champions of the SEC Tournament. Make it sweeter that an automatic bid to the NCAA tourney accompanies that title. And, for the sake of brutal reality, understand that, should you not secure the errant free throw - and subsequently lose, you might be excluded from the field of 65.
So, with all that on the line, sure enough, the Bulldog (purposely unnamed) on the inside failed to have the discipline to get contact with Patrick Patterson, who whirled to the baseline and tipped the ball out to John Wall, who attempted a three-pointer, a shot, that had it dropped, would have won the game right there and then for the Wildcats. As it was, Wall’s shot was short - so short it landed in the hands of Derrick Cousins, who managed to get the shot off an eyelash before the horn sounded and the red light illuminated.
It was so close the referees had to take several looks at it (I was driving at the time and color analyst Kevin Grevey made the comment that he looked at the replay five times and couldn’t decide whether the basket was good or not. Slo-mo replays showed Cousins did get it off in time and the game went into overtime. It didn’t have to. Mississippi State should have conceded. During the time the officials were checking the monitors, there should have been a team vote, saying, “If you say the basket is good, we surrender.”
The teaching point is: with all that on the line, if you can’t give every ounce of energy and effort you have FOR FIVE SECONDS, what makes anyone think you can do it for another five minutes? That missed opportunity (especially the missed block-out) will haunt the Bulldog program for a long, long time - mainly because it was so unnecessary.
That said, do you ever think something like it will ever happen again? If you don’t, take a cue from Douglas Adams:
“Human beings, who are almost unique in having the ability to learn from the experiences of others, are also remarkable for their apparent disinclination to do so.”