After Hearing All (or Most of) the Debate, a Comment on the Mosque Issue
Wednesday, August 25th, 2010Many people in this country have made it their cause (hobby?) to take literal translations of the law and/or Constitution and see how far they can push them. For seven years, I was employed at a workplace that was as petty, dysfunctional and contained more antagonists on “both sides of the aisle” than any other in the nation - the athletics department at Fresno State.
You may know FSU as the school that’s lost more cases (or at least, money) regarding lack of compliance for Title IX than any other school. I was on the “executive council” of the athletics director. At one meeting, we were told by the AD he arranged to bring in the foremost authority on Title IX in the country, a gentleman named Lamar Wright.Â
The atmosphere in and around the office was electric as the day of his arrival approached. Finally, the big day arrived and Lamar visited the campus. For two days, he perused “the books” and on the third day, he addressed our group. He pointed out a couple of, as he referred to them, minor items where the university could have done a better job.Â
Then, he paused and said (I’m not sure this is verbatim - so please don’t sue me - but the gist of the quote is dead on with his analysis), “I’ve been all over the country doing studies such as these and I’ve never seen anything quite like what goes on here. You people count beans!“ In all, Fresno State didn’t lose as much as it got out-lawyered (of course, isn’t that how most cases are won and lost - especially, it seems, in California)?Â
What’s going on with the planned building of the mosque at the site of Ground Zero brings back all too familiar memories. Is it really about the right to worship? Or is there another agenda - in this country which has now embraced as its goal the exact opposite of that of any successful organization, group, team - or country: “What’s right is more important than who’s right?”
There’s no denying the people who are insistent the mosque be built are playing the “It’s our right” card. When asked if the place of worship has to be built right there - on a parcel of land that offends so many people, people who lost loved ones in the 9/11 attack - the supporters deflect the criticism of the location.  “It’s not about where it’s built but that, if denied here, then who’s to say mosques elsewhere will face opposition?” Oh please! It’s all about winning and showing superiority - just like what transpired at Fresno State. Only on a topic that’s of infinitely greater importance and meaning to everyone.
My first year of teaching in the Clovis Unified School District, the administration brought in a terrific speaker, Dr. Bertice Berry, for the General Session to kick off the school year. Dr. Berry made several statements and observations that day. The one that had the greatest impact on me was:
“There’s a big difference between what you HAVE a right to do and what IS right to do.”