On Second Thought…
Thursday, August 30th, 2007When I was in the midst of my 30-year career in the world of intercollegiate coaching, I used to speak before booster groups and joke with the audience that one of the true bonuses of coaching in college was that I got to meet so many absolutely brilliant people. Not only were they experts in their own field, but they could also do our football coach’s job, our basketball coach’s job, our athletic director’s job, - their talents were seemingly limitless. Of course, many of these guys were very average in what they actually did for a living - and would be tremendously insulted if you ever even hinted at a way they could improve their business.
At the time, I wasn’t kidding. When I first got to the University of Tennessee, our football team was struggling and I would hear from friends of mine how pitiful a job the football staff was doing and how they couldn’t believe we didn’t throw more, throw deep more, blitz more, fumble less - you get the idea - all strategical moves they would utilize if only the powers that be would wake up & give the reins to someone who really knew the game, someone who’d been watching football for the better part of 20 years (albeit from the 42nd row). Â
The coaches they were talking about were my colleagues and friends, yet it was assumed I ought to be agreeing with every bit of their wisdom. These people used to say all this to me as if I didn’t know that during basketball season, if we were to lose, I wouldn’t realize they’d be saying the same thing about our staff.Â
Suffice to say I’m somewhat sensitive regarding second guessers. After you’ve been in meetings, practices, locker rooms and watched hundreds of hours of video, you find it hard to listen to someone who, not only thinks he’s an undiscovered genius, but who gets even brighter by the drink. After 1:00 am, you’d think you were talking (listening) to Bill Walsh or John Wooden.
Now that I’m removed from the coaching wars and have been relegated to the role of fan, or even worse, parent, I can see a shred of truth in the critcism from outside sources. I probably knew it then, too, but your defensives are up, you fight back.
The quote that wraps up this blog comes from the former director of USC’s Leadership Institute, Warren Bennis (note this is the second time in the past three days I’ve used a quote from him) who said:
“Receptivity to criticsm is as necessary as it is loathsome. And the more valid the criticism, the more difficult it is to receive.”Â