Coaching Contracts Should Work Both Ways
Wednesday, January 30th, 2008Back in the day, as the saying goes, hiring coaches used to be an athletics director offering the job to the guy he wanted, shaking his hand and off to work they’d both go. Since then things have changed for the better - and the worse.
Rich Rodriquez was the golden boy of West Virginia - born and raised there, a guy who went to WVU as a walk-on, earned a scholarship, later coached at his alma mater as a student, then as a volunteer assistant, (in between he coached at two small colleges in the state - a state with a great deal of pride, sticking closely together due to the fact so many others ridicule it as a backwoods section of the country). I heard current Creighton University basketball coach, Dana Altman, who had coached at Marshall University in Huntington, WV, tell a joke at a coaching clinic that the definition of “foreplay” in West Virginia is, “Hey, sis, you up yet?” Not surprisingly, not too many West Virginians (as well as several others in the crowd) thought that was very funny, but it showed a prevailing attitude of some people toward the way of life in the Mountaineer State.
Then how did Rodriquez, who took WVU to unprecedented heights on the gridiron (leading them to BCS bowls), become such a despised figure in his home state? Ironically, it was something he said that made the people of West Virginia revere him, then revile him. After being courted by the University of Alabama, a school as rich in football tradition as any in the nation, “Rod” turned back the Tide, claiming, “When the details (of the new contract with WVU) come out, you’ll see that I’m committed to West Virginia University for a very, very long time.” This is exactly what a state with a blue collar mentality (albeit one where the once-highly profitable coal mining business has taken a major hit) wanted to hear.
It’s just that to those people, the phrase “a very, very long time” meant more than a year, which is exactly what happened when another school with a deep football roots, the University of Michigan, came courting following this season. What made Rodriguez leave? Was it the devastating loss to a lowly Pitt team which kept the Mountaineers from playing in the national championship game? Did he feel he had maxed out what he could do at WVU and needed a fresh challenge at a school that many so-called experts think is one that can compete for a national championship every year?
And then there was the paper trail, how moves were made at such a time as to force WVU’s hand and other various and sundry items that the reader can research elsewhere. The fact of the matter is the world has changed. Trust is no longer the cherished commodity it used to be. Lawyers and agents have entered the mix (and have found a way to make gobs of money doing it).
Coaches used to be on one year deals. Walter Alston of the beloved Dodgers of my youth had something like 25 one-year contracts. I can’t recall Woody Hayes, Vince Lombardi or John Wooden negotiating for long-term deals, either. However, when recruiting became dirty (dirtier) and rivals used age and job security against their fellow coaches and owners began getting trigger happy when franchises didn’t win big enough or often enough, coaches went into survival mode.Â
It helped to be able to tell a recruit you had a long-term deal or if a club wasn’t performing as expected and the boss wanted to “go in a different direction,” that the coach had something to tide him over until he hoped to land on his feet. The pendulum had swung. However, as pendulums are apt to do, it began its reverse arc.
Sam Jankovich, then-Washington State’s AD saw newly hired Jackie Sherrill come in (allegedly to get some head coaching experience under his belt before returning to Pitt to replace Johnny Majors, only to leave after a year when Pitt unexpectedly accelerated their football ascent and won the National Championship, sending Johnny Majors marching home to the University of Tennessee). Off Jackie went, breaking a multi-year deal which, had he gotten fired, would have given him a huge severance package. Next up was Warren Powers who also signed a multi-year deal expecting to lead the Cougars for many deasons, but then his alma mater unexpectedly came calling and, as much as he hated to leave (everyone I know at WSU - my alma mater - said he was a good and decent man), couldn’t turn down “Momma calling.”
Except Sam, a former coach, was also a brilliant business man. He saw this as what it was - a totally one-sided agreement in favor of the coach … and he demanded Powers buy out the remaining years on his deal. Thus, was the two-way, negotiable coaching contract born.
I’ve never understood why coaches were allowed to walk out on a long-term deal, yet expected compensation if they were terminated. Kind of a “what’s good for the goose…” scenario. Now, there are specialists on both sides writing contracts. Doesn’t do much for the once highly regarded “trust” factor, but, unfortunately, the age of trust has long since past.
I’ve already blogged about the problem of paying the head man too much (see 11/28/07) and now we have both sides represented, resulting in nothing less than a contentious undertaking. I hate it when people say, “In the good old days,” but there is something to be said for that part of the past.
What do you know? Back-to-back days with Albert Einstein quotes:
“Not everything that can be counted counts and not everything that counts can be counted.”    Â